Kalen DeBoer took the head coaching job for the Alabama Crimson Tide with a reputation for elite offensive design, player development, and program stability. In his first two seasons, Alabama showed flashes of being a national‑title caliber team, especially in marquee matchups against Georgia, LSU, and other high‑profile opponents.
But the Tide also showed something far less familiar to Alabama fans: inconsistency. The team that rose to the occasion against top‑tier competition sometimes looked unrecognizable against lesser opponents. That’s the gap DeBoer must close in Year 3.
Alabama Needs To Find An Identity
Nick Saban’s Alabama teams were known for one thing above all else: you knew exactly what you were getting every Saturday. The opponent didn’t matter. The venue didn’t matter. The ranking didn’t matter. The standard was the standard, and most of the time, the Tide did not deviate from that.
DeBoer’s Alabama hasn’t reached that point yet. But that’s not to say they can’t.
Creating an identity is difficult, especially when you are following someone like Saban. The longer DeBoer is in Tuscaloosa, the more it feels like he is leaving his mark on the program.
DeBoer can start to silence many, if not most of his critics, if his offense can find a more consistent ground game.
DeBoer’s system works. Now it needs to work every week.
Alabama Must Eliminate Up-And-Down Play
Some of Alabama’s best performances under DeBoer have come against the best teams on the schedule. Such as ending UGA’s 33-game home winning streak in 2025. Or going on the road and destroying LSU in Death Valley in 2024. Those performances are admirable, but it’s also a red flag.
Championship teams don’t just win the big games. They dominate the ones they’re supposed to dominate, and under DeBoer, that hasn’t really been the case.
Whether it was road losses to underwhelming Vanderbilt and Oklahoma teams in 2024 or the 2025 season-opening defeat to a Florida State squad that finished just 5–7, DeBoer has to ensure his team brings the same level of intensity no matter who’s on the schedule.
Year 3 Is About Raising the Floor, Not the Ceiling
Kalen DeBoer has already shown he can get Alabama to play elite football. The ceiling is high enough to win championships. The question for Year 3 is whether he can raise the floor.
If Alabama becomes a team that shows up every Saturday—regardless of opponent, ranking, or circumstance, the Tide will be right back where the fanbase expects them to be.
Consistency is the missing piece. Year 3 is the time to fix it.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post The One Problem Kalen DeBoer Must Fix in Year 3 at Alabama appeared first on Heavy Sports.