When Justin Verlander is finally inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame, people will talk a lot about what cap will be on his plaque. According to Evan Petzold from the Detroit Free Press, the veteran right-hander says he isn’t ready to answer that question yet, but the numbers and the legacy he built over the past ten years make a strong case.
Verlander should wear the Houston Astros cap in Cooperstown if he had to pick one today.
That might sound strange at first. Verlander played for the Detroit Tigers for the first 13 years of his career and became one of the best pitchers in baseball during that time. But the Hall of Fame isn’t just about where a player spent the most time. It’s about where their legacy was finally set.
That defining chapter for Verlander happened in Houston.
Houston Turned Verlander Into a Legendary Second-Act Star
Verlander made his first appearance with the Tigers in 2005 and quickly became the face of the team’s pitching staff. In 2006, he won the American League Rookie of the Year award. In 2011, he won the AL Cy Young Award and the AL MVP Award, both at a higher level. That was one of the few times a pitcher has won the league’s MVP award.
Verlander had 183 wins and pitched more than 2,500 innings while he was in Detroit, making him one of the best starters of his time.
But the next stage of his life changed how people will remember him.
Verlander was already in his mid-30s when the Astros got him in August 2017. A lot of pitchers his age start to get worse, but Verlander instead had one of the best late-career comebacks in the history of the sport.
He had a 2.71 ERA in 810.1 innings with Houston and won two more Cy Young Awards in 2019 and 2022. That run made him not just a great pitcher, but a great one in history.
Verlander also became a key player in one of the most successful baseball dynasties of the modern era. During his time with the team, the Astros made the playoffs every year and won two World Series titles.
Those years didn’t just add to his career. They changed the story about it.
Championships and Legacy Often Decide the Cap Choice
A Hall of Fame plaque cap usually shows where a player had the biggest impact, and for Verlander, that place is probably Houston.
His time in Detroit was great, but he also came close to missing out in October. The Tigers made it to the World Series in 2006 and 2012, but they didn’t win either time.
Verlander became known for winning championships in Houston.
He came late in the 2017 season and quickly helped the team make the playoffs, where they won the World Series. Years later, after Tommy John surgery, he was back at the top of the league and helped Houston win another championship in 2022.
People will remember Verlander’s later years differently because of those times. He wasn’t just a top pitcher who kept track of his stats. He was the best player on a team that always had a chance to win.
Verlander’s Hall of Fame career started in Detroit. He became a superstar there and built up the stats that will eventually get him to Cooperstown.
But Houston gave him the most important part.
Verlander was able to change his game and keep winning in the sport well into his 30s. They made him a symbol of longevity, strength, and championship wins.
A Hall of Fame legacy is usually made up of that mix.
Verlander might not be ready to pick a cap yet, and since he wants to pitch until he’s 45 and get 300 career wins, that choice might not come for a few more years.
But when the time comes, the Astros cap may tell the most complete story of his career.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Astros, Not Tigers, Should Be Justin Verlander’s Hall of Fame Cap appeared first on Heavy Sports.