Dramatic change would be required to fix California’s homebuying affordability mess.
Related Articles
Morgan Hill welcomes 73 units of affordable housing to help farmworkers, homeless residents
Big housing development with several hundred units is eyed in San Jose
Hundreds of affordable apartments targeted for former Orchard Supply Hardware site in East San Jose
San Jose housing tower lands fresh $150 million loan in hopeful sign
UC Berkeley student housing construction at People’s Park site going as planned
My trusty spreadsheet compared home-price increases with income growth for 10 large California metropolitan areas using housing indexes by ICE, a mortgage-tech firm, and pay stats from the US Bureau of Economic Analysis.
First, consider the estimated median house payment for these California metros.
In 2018, payments on the typical $509,400 home purchase ran $2,020 monthly with an average 4.3% mortgage rate, assuming a 20% downpayment.
That was 22% of a typical house hunter’s $109,100 income, including two earners.
Then, contemplate the payment on today’s $759,500 median-priced home. The payment doubled to $4,000 monthly with 6.9% rates.
The mortgage now gobbles up 32% of the $148,500 income that risen 36% in six years.
So, what would it take to return this payment burden to pre-coronavirus levels?
Rates would have to fall to 3.5%. Incomes would need to surge 50%. And prices would need to drop 33%. Or some combination of the three.
This lack of affordability is why one-third fewer California homes will be sold this year than in 2018.
How did we get here?
Remember that the housing market was upended by several things during the pandemic: a demand for more living space, mortgage rates under 3% and stimulus checks boosting incomes.
Now let’s look at how six years of home appreciation through October contrasts with rising per-capita incomes during the six years ending in 2023.
In eight of these 10 California metros, home-price gains outpaced incomes. Here’s how they ranked by the gap …
Bakersfield: 63% gains in home values compared with 29% income growth.
Inland Empire: 65% home gain vs. 37% income growth.
San Diego: 66% home gain vs. 39% income growth.
Fresno: 60% home gain vs. 33% income growth.
Ventura County: 51% home gain vs. 36% income growth.
LA-OC: 50% home gain vs. 39% income growth.
Sacramento: 46% home gain vs. 35% income growth.
Stockton: 50% home gain vs. 45% income growth.
And in two California metros, incomes beat home prices …
San Jose: 34% home gains topped by 54% income growth.
San Francisco: 26% home gains topped by 46% income growth.
Sliver of hope
For homebuyers, a little bit of good news: appreciation is cooling.
Price gains in the 12 months ending in October were significantly smaller than the previous five-year appreciation pace in all but one of the 10 metros.
San Diego saw the biggest chill, with prices rising 3.2% in the past year – down from annual average gains of 9.9% between 2018 and 2023. That is a 6.7-percentage-point cooldown.
San Jose was the lone spot without a dip in appreciation. Its 5.1% year’s gain was a smidgen above the 5% yearly increases of 2018-23.
Here’s how the nine other metros fared by ICE math, ranked by appreciation chill …
Inland Empire: 3.5% year’s gain vs. averaging 9.8% annual increases in 2018-23 – 6.3 points cooler.
Sacramento: 1.7% year’s gain vs. 7.5% annually in 2018-23 – 5.8 points cooler.
Bakersfield: 4.1% year’s gain vs. up 9.4% annually in 2018-23 – 5.3 points cooler.
Stockton: 2.9% year’s gain vs. up 7.9% annually in 2018-23 – 5 points cooler.
Ventura County: 3.3% year’s gain vs. up 7.9% yearly in 2018-23 – 4.7 points cooler.
Fresno: 4.2% year’s gain vs. up 8.9% annually in 2018-23 – 4.7 points cooler.
Los Angeles-Orange County: 3.9% year’s gain vs. up 7.7% annually in 2018-23 – 3.7 points cooler.
San Francisco: 1.3% year’s gain vs. up 4.4% annually in 2018-23 – 3.1 points cooler.
But smaller home price gains are by no means a cure, because “affordability” really means lowering prices.
Jonathan Lansner is the business columnist for the Southern California News Group. He can be reached at jlansner@scng.com