As the 2024 U.S. election draws closer, a dark facet of the media world has some in the industry on edge: a particular type of fake news website that is designed to appear legitimate. The ubiquity of these sites has led to a rise in what those in the news business call “pink-slime journalism.”
The problem is becoming more pervasive as it becomes harder to discern real news stories from phony ones. While not solely focused on politics, these fake news websites, which are seen on both sides of the political aisle, will likely continue to play a looming role in the election and beyond. What is pink-slime journalism, and why is it making reporters so nervous?
What is ‘pink-slime journalism?’
Named after a meat byproduct, pink-slime journalism describes “outlets that publish poor quality reports that appear to be local news,” said the Poynter Institute. In other words, they are fake news websites posing as legitimate sources of local news. The rise of pink-slime journalism can be almost directly tied to the demise of local newspapers in recent years.
Many of these low-profile local publications, especially in small towns, have “either gone out of business or are struggling to survive,” and pink-slime websites have cropped up in their place, said the Poynter Institute. They often slide under the radar by claiming to “cover local and hyperlocal news, sometimes taking advantage of news deserts.” And unlike actual newspapers, pink-slime journalism is mostly “produced via automation and templates.”
How many of these websites are there?
The exact amount is unclear, but they have been on a steady rise ahead of the election, and do not appear to be going away. There are at least 1,265 identifiable websites that claim to be independent news outlets but are really pink-slime publications, according to a recent report from the misinformation watchdog group NewsGuard.
In comparison, there are only 1,213 daily local newspapers left in the United States, according to Northwestern University’s Local News Initiative. The fact that there are now more pink-slime publications than genuine local publications in the U.S. has shined a spotlight on the omnipresence of misinformation in the media landscape.
Who is behind these websites?
Within the identified pink-slime websites in NewsGuard’s report, there are “eight primary organizations that have been identified as supporting most of the sites identified — four lean conservative and four lean progressive,” said Axios. The majority of the sites were created at the behest of the conservative network Metric Media. Most of Metric Media’s sites “don’t include much information about the sites’ funders or management,” and typically “lack bylines and many are outdated or marked as ‘press release submissions.'”
Other organizations identified by Axios as backing pink-slime websites are Courier Newsroom and States Newsroom. Both reportedly receive donations from left-wing backers; Courier Newsroom “aims to tackle disinformation by funding local newsrooms with a progressive perspective,” while States Newsroom was “incubated originally via a left-leaning nonprofit called The Hopewell Fund.”
Some of these pink-slime outlets are almost immediately identifiable as fake. One website called Chicago City Wire recently ran an article on an “upcoming local event about decriminalizing sex work under the salacious headline ‘Hookers and chicken parm,'” said Ars Technica. This article “has no named byline and does not mention chicken parm apart from in its headline.” Instead, it “taps into ongoing American culture wars, labeling a local LGBTQ+ organization as a ‘pro-homosexual and cross-dresser rights group.'”
Beyond American borders, Russian disinformation is reportedly playing a role in the rise of pink-slime as well. A separate report from NewsGuard found that a Florida man was fronting a network of at least 167 Russian disinformation websites being disseminated across the web.
And while the majority of pink-slime is found online, print journalism is not entirely immune; physical newspapers are allegedly often used to target voters in several states. This past April, the Illinois State Board of Elections asked the state’s attorney general to investigate a pink-slime publication used by the same conservative backer of Metric Media in 2022. The “DuPage Policy Journal” was disseminated across northern Illinois and designed to look like a real newspaper, but was actually part of a far-right GOP campaign, the Chicago Tribune reported.
“It is disappointing when an organization shows such little regard for voters,” said Bernadette Matthews, the Illinois board’s executive director, per the Tribune.