Irish citizens will go to the polls on Friday to choose a new government, and it’s far from certain who will lead the next administration
With days to go, the incumbent centrist coalition of Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, led by Taoiseach Simon Harris, looked set to regain enough votes to continue in power. But a “brusque exchange” between Harris and a voter on the campaign trail has really “churned the waters”, said Mark Landler in The New York Times.
In an election likely to be defined by issues of immigration, housing and jobs that could result in a bigger-than-usual vote for independent candidates, it may well be some time before the make-up of the next government is known.
What did the commentators say?
Given Ireland’s unusual proportional-representation voting system, candidates are elected “slowly”, said David Blevins and Conor O’Neill at Sky News. And, with no party having “fielded enough to win a majority”, there will certainly be a coalition government.
This “peculiarly Irish race” favours Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, the parties that have “produced every prime minister” since 1922, said Shawn Pogatchnik at Politico. “The two big legacy parties,” said Melanie McDonagh in The Spectator, “manifestly have more in common than not.”
Sinn Fein has “gained momentum” but is “limited by a lack of coalition partners”, said Jill Lawless at The Washington Post, just as it was when it won the popular vote in 2020. It has also recently “been dogged by a series of allegations of inappropriate behaviour”, said The Guardian‘s Justine McCarthy. It is unlikely to find an ally among the two big parties, who are wary of its “leftist policies and historic links to the Irish Republican Army”, said Lawless.
All three parties are likely to feel the heat of some voters “turning on them” in favour of one of “several smaller parties” and an “assortment of independents” who have all taken up positions away from the centre ground.
Sinn Fein, in particular, is being “stung by the anti-immigrant sentiment” that has swept Ireland. Its leaders, having “largely shunned the nativist language of populist and right-wing parties”, are seeing some of their base “peeling away” to independent and fringe candidates, added The New York Times’ Landler.
For Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil, there’s likely to be backlash over their perceived lack of answers to the housing crisis. This is “among the main concerns of voters”, with many “basing their first-preference intentions” on party stances on this issue, said Jade Wilson and Conor Pope in The Irish Times.
And, for Fine Gael, it could be Harris’ “moment of Veep-grade awkwardness” on the campaign trail that weakens them most, and unseats him as Taoiseach, said Pogatchnik at Politico.
What next?
Whoever is able to form a coalition will have a slew of issues to deal with. As well as the housing crisis, high prices and the cost of living remain “a key concern”, said Jon Henley in The Guardian.
Then there’s healthcare funding, the “hot-button” issue of immigration, and the “less vexed” question of how to spend the €14bn of tax money coming to the country from Apple after an EU high-court ruling.
Any election result leaves Irish politics in a “strange blend of continuity and flux”, said Eoin Daly on The Conversation. While the recent coalition governments have kept a “façade of relative stability”, the nature of the electoral set-up points to a “longer-term trend towards discord and disintegration” – something that will be “familiar across much of the European continent”.
The most probably outcome is a Fine Gael/Fianna Fáil coalition, in tandem with a smaller party. All the independents together “could get up to a fifth of the vote”, said The Spectator’s McDonagh, and any conservative independents who sign up with a Fianna Fáil / Fine Gael coalition “may be the tail to wag the government dog”.
Taoiseach Simon Harris, says McDonagh, may get “more than he bargained for” in calling this election.