Democratic U.S. Rep. Yadira Caraveo and her Republican challenger, state Rep. Gabe Evans, sparred over immigration, abortion and Donald Trump on Tuesday night in the first debate for one of the most tightly contested congressional contests in the country.
The debate, hosted by 9News, was the first of two scheduled ahead of their November race to represent the northern suburbs of the 8th Congressional District. Many of the questions focused on immigration, a topic that both Evans and Caraveo have embraced, though the 30-minute debate included rapid-fire topic changes that touched on abortion, housing, corporal punishment of children, and a series of anti-immigrant statements made by Trump, the Aurora-bound Republican presidential candidate that moderator Kyle Clark linked to fascist rhetoric of the 1930s and ’40s.
Much of the debate saw moderators prod the candidates — and Evans in particular — to directly answer questions. Asked if he would condemn Trump’s anti-immigrant statements or describe them as racist, for instance, Evans, a freshman state lawmaker from Fort Lupton endorsed by Trump, said he focused on policy and twice obliquely repeated that he had “always condemned racist statements.”
Evans did indicate he didn’t support Trump’s desire to deport every undocumented immigrant in the country, though he broadly backed more intensive border security efforts and criticized Caraveo and Democratic lawmakers’ handling of immigration issues.
“We have to aggressively target those individuals who are illegally in our communities, committing crimes, and those are the folks that we have to deport,” he said.
Evans also would not answer directly when asked if it was appropriate to use corporal punishment on children in schools, in relation to a bill he voted against last year. He at first said that “we need to ensure that we are providing a safe place to be able to learn in our public schools.” When pressed to answer directly, he began talking about his past work as a “part-time school resource officer.” Clark then stopped him and moved on.
Caraveo, who joined a small group of Democrats this summer in backing a Republican resolution condemning Vice President Kamala Harris’ handling of the border, said her disavowal of some of her previous immigration positions — like defunding immigration law enforcement — was a reflection of a shift in the country.
“I think the country has changed, and we’ve seen a crisis that both parties have set up and not offered solutions for,” Caraveo said, in a nod to the bipartisan bona fides she’s sought to bolster in a district she won by fewer than 1,700 votes two years ago.
Caraveo said she would vote to represent her constituents, apparently meaning a more enforcement-heavy approach. She would not say if she still supported giving government contracts to companies that employ undocumented workers, saying only that her constituents wanted a “balanced” approach.
Congresswoman Yadira Caraveo, the Democratic incumbent, left, and Republican state Rep. Gabe Evans, right, participate in an 8th congressional debate at the 9News studio in Denver, Colorado on Tuesday, Oct. 8, 2024. (Photos by Hyoung Chang/The Denver Post)
Related Articles
Amendment J would repeal Colorado’s defunct ban on same-sex marriage from constitution
Amendment K would tighten some of Colorado’s election deadlines
Amendment G would extend Colorado’s homestead property tax exemption to more veterans
Amendment I would let Colorado judges deny bail to first-degree murder defendants
Ballot Issue 4A asks voters to approve a nearly $1 billion bond for Denver Public Schools
She said she would have supported the bipartisan border bill that Trump scuttled earlier this year, and she accused Republicans of not being serious about immigration.
“Donald Trump decided that he would rather run on the issue of immigration than give me the opportunity to vote on it,” she said.
Evans criticized Caraveo’s support for a 2019 state law that, among other things, bars local law enforcement from providing someone’s immigration status to federal authorities. (Asked twice whether she stood by that policy, Caraveo said it “shouldn’t be up to local law enforcement to do what the federal government has failed to do.”)
Beyond immigration, Caraveo touted her work at the state level to limit late fees charged to tenants, and Evans boosted his own bipartisan credentials by noting that he’d passed a majority of his bills during his time in the legislature, despite serving in a chamber that Democrats control at supermajority levels.
On abortion, Evans said he did not support a national ban on abortion access and that he supported exemptions when the mother’s life is in danger or in cases of rape or incest. Caraveo said she supported codifying Roe vs. Wade, the now-moot Supreme Court case that for decades provided base-level abortion access in America, into law.
Stay up-to-date with Colorado Politics by signing up for our weekly newsletter, The Spot.