The Tyler Allgeier Broncos idea picked up real traction on Feb. 25, after former Denver quarterback Ben DiNucci publicly backed the Broncos as a landing spot for the Falcons running back, specifically as a potential 1-2 punch with Broncos RB RJ Harvey.
DiNucci replied to a free-agency prompt that highlighted Allgeierâs expected price point, and he didnât hedge. âBroncos,â DiNucci wrote, adding that a â1, 2 punch with him and Harvey would cause problems.â
Why today? With the NFL calendar turning toward the roster-building stretch (Combine week into free agency), Denverâs backfield plans are a live topic, and Allgeier is now being framed as a specific, premium addition tied to a reported contract ask.
Key Points
- Ex-Broncos QB Ben DiNucci endorsed Denver as a fit for a free-agent RB addition.
- The discussion centers on Tyler Allgeier and a projected deal âin the neighborhood ofâ 3 years, $22 million.
- DiNucci explicitly mentioned a pairing with RJ Harvey, adding urgency to how Denver might build its 2026 RB room.Â
NFL Rumors: Tyler Allgeier Broncos buzz gets louder thanks to Ben DiNucciÂ
The money is what makes this spicy.
The Athleticâs Josh Kendall reported that Allgeier will seek a contract around three years, $22 million this offseason, and that itâs likely more than Atlanta will want to pay with future budgeting in mind.
Thatâs not fringe-back pricing. At roughly $7.3 million per year, thatâs the type of number that signals a player (and agent) expecting more than just âchange-of-paceâ usage.
A quick reality check on Denverâs decision tree
- If Denver is paying starter-level money, it usually means starter-level touches are on the table.
- If the Broncos view RJ Harvey as a true three-down option, then adding Allgeier at that price implies either (a) a deliberate committee, or (b) uncertainty about workload durability across a full season. Denver hasnât publicly acknowledged the direction its leaningÂ
How a Tyler Allgeier-RJ Harvey pairing could look in Sean Paytonâs offense
DiNucciâs â1-2 punchâ line matters because it points to role clarity: Denver wouldnât be chasing Allgeier to sit.
A logical split could look like this:
- Allgeier: early-down hammer, four-minute offense, interior runs, closer when protecting leads.
- Harvey: space touches, screens/choice routes, outside concepts, tempo packages.
What it changes on Sundays
- It can keep both backs fresher late-season.
- It can change Denverâs play-calling menu near the goal line and on second-and-medium, where Payton historically likes to stay out of obvious pass downs.
Any stronger running back pairing could make life easier for Broncos QB Bo Nix, as he comes back from an ankle injury that ended his season in the playoffs.
The contract mechanics Denver would have to navigate
Allgeier at 3/$22M likely requires real structure decisions: signing bonus, Year 1 cap hit, and guarantees.
What to look for if this becomes real
- Guarantees: Is it effectively a 1-year deal with team outs, or a true multi-year commitment?
- Year 1 cap number: Denver can lower it with bonus proration, but that pushes money into future seasons.
- Roster fit domino: A meaningful Allgeier deal could squeeze the rest of the RB room depending on who is under contract and who can be stashed on the practice squad.
What Denver has signaled about the backfield lately
Denver has shown it will keep adding to the RB room when value appears. For example, the Broncos signed J.K. Dobbins in 2025, a move that was widely framed as depth/competition at the position.
And DiNucci isnât just a random commentator; he has been part of the Broncosâ orbit, including a recent practice-squad stint noted by the team.
That context doesnât make the Tyler Allgeier Broncos fit inevitable, but it explains why his endorsement traveled.
Like Heavy Sports’s content? Be sure to follow us.
This article was originally published on Heavy Sports
The post Ex-Broncos QB Drops a Bold Free-Agent RB Suggestion for Bo Nix appeared first on Heavy Sports.