SACRAMENTO – If California progressivism were the answer to Donald Trump’s MAGA-inspired populist bluster, then we’d be watching news of President-elect Kamala Harris’ Cabinet appointments. Instead Trump swept the swing states, won the popular vote and saw Republicans secure control of both houses of Congress. The message voters sent might not be entirely clear, but they certainly didn’t say, “We want California values!”
Harris, of course, was a product of the San Francisco Bay Area political machine. Her tenure in the U.S. Senate was marked by support for standard-issue progressive platitudes. She wisely tacked to the center, but never detailed a compelling alternative agenda – although she did walk back some of her more-liberal positions. One cannot defeat something with nothing, even if the something is ominous.
There’s cause for concern as the Trump Show 2.0 unfolds. Some early picks – such as U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio of Florida for secretary of state – are perfectly reasonable. My initial social-media post wondered whether after all the fuss we’d just end up with a relatively normal Republican administration. Fortunately, I quickly deleted my X post. Shortly thereafter, Trump announced some doozies.
The funniest thing about choosing U.S. Rep. Matt Gaetz, R-Fla., for attorney general is it actually was a relief compared to other possible choices. Even many Republicans expressed shock at Gaetz, who resigned from Congress before the House would vote on releasing an ethics report considering “allegations that he may have engaged in sexual misconduct and illegal drug use and accepted improper gifts,” The Washington Post explained.
Don’t worry. Those same “principled” Republicans will soon dutifully support the selection, just as they will publicly applaud Tulsi Gabbard as director of national intelligence. The former Democratic House member is well known for taking positions that seem popular in Moscow. They’ll also cheer his plan for recess appointments. Whatever. I’m at the “just bring popcorn” stage of the circus.
Democrats are understandably in disarray. So are Never Trumpers and other non-Democrats who take seriously Trump’s promises and trial balloons (mass deportations, joking that Congress should find a way for him to run for a third term). It’s all fun and games until it isn’t. Granted, this is a long and convoluted path to my main point: To deflect further assaults on democratic norms, Trump’s foes will need a skilled, focused and thoughtful leader.
It’s not news to this newspaper’s readers, but Gov. Gavin Newsom is not that person. Yet he’s positioning himself and our state as the bulwark of Trump resistance. Newsom last week announced an emergency legislative session to “safeguard California values and fundamental rights in the face of an incoming Trump administration.” It will muster “legal resources to protect civil rights, reproductive freedom, climate action and immigrant families.”
Mind you, this governor and Legislature have yet to make a dent in any of the state’s pressing homegrown problems: a sprawling homelessness problem, crime wave, housing unaffordability, fleeing businesses. Newsom was first elected governor in 2018 – two years into the first Trump term – and hasn’t set the state on a sound course. Voters have been forced to take matters into their own hands, mostly at the ballot box and usually against the advice of the Newsom. See the Proposition 36 anti-crime measure for an example.
Furthermore, the governor’s last extraordinary session was a transparent public-relations stunt. Upset at California’s gasoline prices (around $1.50 a gallon above the national average), Newsom blamed corporate greed and signed a law that forces oil companies to maintain larger reserves – a costly regulation that might increase prices further. Never mind the state’s policies (high gas taxes, special fuels mandate and a push to end fossil-fuels production) are the real causes of crushing gas prices.
Related Articles
Let the games begin: 2026 campaign for California governor now looms
California see-saws back to tough on crime with passage of Proposition 36
Carl DeMaio’s plan to restore the California GOP and save the Golden State
Kamala Harris’ ‘perfect campaign’ and other bad takes from the 2024 election
Federal waivers for California environmental policies should be denied
Meanwhile, Newsom’s own California Air Resources Board appointees recently OK’d a new low-carbon fuels rule that CARB staffers said could boost per-gallon prices by 47 cents (and by $1.80 by 2040). The board has since made those estimates disappear, but a prominent independent study by the University of Pennsylvania Kleinman Center for Energy Policy has confirmed that the price “impacts could be $0.65 per gallon in the near term.”
Bottom line: The Legislature is generally ineffective at anything and these special sessions merely become backdrops for photo ops. For the past couple of years, Gov. Gavin Newsom barnstormed the country promoting California “democracy” even as the administration pulled out the stops to keep a tax-limiting initiative off the ballot. I’m sure Trump supporters are as fearful of Newsom’s new effort as they were of his last one.
Part of the problem is California Democrats operate in a one-party state, where they face virtually no ideological or partisan opposition and must only navigate that insular backroom world. California leaders can’t serve as the focus of the Trump resistance because no one outside of California takes them seriously. That’s too bad, because the new Trump term will need serious pushback.
Steven Greenhut is Western region director for the R Street Institute and a member of the Southern California News Group editorial board. Write to him at sgreenhut@rstreet.org.